Mesh Safety Cover vs. Solid Safety Covers: Which is Better for Long Island Winters?

When it comes to safeguarding your pool during the harsh Long Island winters, safety covers are an essential investment. They not only protect your pool from debris and weather elements but also provide an added layer of safety. Among safety covers, both mesh and solid options are available, each with its unique advantages. In this comparison guide, we’ll explore the benefits of both mesh and solid safety covers, considering Long Island’s winter climate. By understanding the strengths of each type, you can make an informed decision that ensures your pool’s protection and enhances safety.

Advantages of Mesh Safety Covers:

  1. Water Drainage:Long Island’s winter weather can be unpredictable, bringing both rain and snow. Mesh safety covers are designed with superior water drainage in mind. They allow rain and snowmelt to drain through the cover, preventing the buildup of excess water. This drainage helps maintain the cover’s integrity and prevents sagging or damage due to standing water.
  2. Debris Prevention:Mesh safety covers excel at preventing larger debris such as leaves, branches, and twigs from entering the pool. Long Island’s fall season can bring a significant amount of debris, and a mesh safety cover effectively keeps this debris out of the pool, reducing the need for extensive cleaning come spring.
  3. Algae Control:The permeable nature of mesh safety covers allows sunlight to penetrate through the cover. This sunlight exposure helps control algae growth during the winter months, minimizing the need for algaecide treatments and reducing maintenance efforts in the spring.

Advantages of Solid Safety Covers:

  1. Total Debris Prevention:Solid safety covers offer complete protection against debris by preventing any contaminants from entering the pool. This feature is particularly beneficial during Long Island’s fall season when leaves and debris are abundant.
  2. Sunlight Blockage:Solid safety covers completely block sunlight from reaching the pool water. By doing so, they effectively prevent algae growth during the winter. The absence of sunlight minimizes the chances of algae blooms and significantly reduces the maintenance required to address algae-related issues.
  3. Durability:Long Island winters can bring heavy snow, ice, and unpredictable weather conditions. Solid safety covers are known for their durability and ability to withstand the weight of snow and other winter elements. They provide long-lasting protection and require minimal maintenance.


The choice between a mesh safety cover and a solid safety cover for your Long Island pool ultimately depends on your priorities and preferences. Mesh safety covers offer excellent water drainage, debris prevention, and moderate algae control. On the other hand, solid safety covers provide total debris protection, block sunlight to prevent algae growth, and offer enhanced durability against harsh winter conditions. Consider the specific climate and needs of Long Island, as well as your safety and maintenance preferences, when making your decision. At Big Becks, we understand the unique requirements of Long Island pool owners, and our expert safety cover services are here to help you choose the best option for both pool protection and safety. Contact us today to ensure your pool is well-prepared for the winter months ahead.


Contact Us

Big Becks Contact Us